An Unwanted Guest by Shari Lapena is a chilling, suspenseful thriller in which a weekend retreat turns deadly when a blizzard isolates the guests, and mysterious murders begin, leaving them struggling to uncover the killer among them.
About
Book Title: An Unwanted Guest
Author: Shari Lapena
ISBN: 978-0525557623
Genre: Fiction, Mystery, Thriller, Suspense
Published Year: 2018
In-Depth Summary of An Unwanted Guest
Shari Lapena’s An Unwanted Guest is a gripping whodunit inspired by Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None, centering on a remote mountain inn and a group of strangers who quickly find themselves in a life-or-death struggle as guests start to die mysteriously. Stranded by a snowstorm, they must survive as they unravel the disturbing possibility that the killer could be one of their own. Lapena builds the tension through a cast of multi-layered characters, combining atmosphere, suspense, and psychological drama.
1. Setting and Atmosphere
The story is set in the isolated and luxurious Mitchell’s Inn, located deep in the woods of the Catskills and renowned for its rustic charm. The inn, decorated in classic style with roaring fireplaces, cozy rooms, and no modern amenities, is meant to be an idyllic retreat from the chaos of daily life. However, the charm turns ominous as a severe snowstorm leaves the guests trapped without power or access to the outside world. The blizzard, with its howling winds and unrelenting snow, creates an atmosphere of claustrophobic tension and impending danger, setting the stage for a weekend of terror.
2. Introduction of Key Characters
The guests at Mitchell’s Inn each have their own reasons for visiting, with secrets and hidden tensions among them. Lapena weaves their backgrounds seamlessly into the plot, using their differences and pasts to add depth and suspense.
David Paley:
A successful criminal defense attorney with a quiet, composed demeanor. David’s career has exposed him to violence and deception, which gives him an edge when panic ensues among the guests.Lauren and Ian:
A young, beautiful couple looking to reconnect. Their relationship is strained, and under the surface, there are unresolved issues that make them tense. Lauren is high-strung and easily frightened, while Ian is calm and observant, hiding his own frustrations.Dana Hart and Matthew Hutchinson:
An engaged couple, both glamorous and seemingly perfect. Dana is a successful lawyer, and Matthew is charismatic. However, their relationship dynamics reveal a power struggle beneath their polished facade.Beverly and Henry Sullivan:
A married couple facing serious marital challenges. Beverly hopes the trip will reignite their connection, while Henry is distant and frustrated, longing for change. Their unresolved resentments add to the tension.Candice White:
An author on a personal retreat to work on her latest novel. Reclusive and observant, Candice is intrigued by the unfolding drama around her, analyzing the other guests as she would characters in a book.Gwen Delaney and Riley Shuter:
Old college friends with contrasting personalities. Gwen is calm and introspective, while Riley has a troubled past and struggles with anxiety and trauma. Their friendship forms a vital support as events unfold.
3. Plot Summary
Arrival and Initial Tension
The story opens with the guests arriving at Mitchell’s Inn, eager for a relaxing weekend. They are greeted by James Harwood, the innkeeper, who does his best to make them comfortable. As they settle in, the forecasted snowstorm intensifies, cutting off communication and trapping everyone inside without electricity. Initially, the guests are unnerved but continue with their plans, drinking wine and engaging in small talk. However, underlying tensions are present, as many of them have secrets they are reluctant to share.
The First Murder
On the first night, Dana Hart is found dead at the bottom of the staircase. Initially, the guests suspect an accident, but as they assess her injuries and position, it becomes evident that she may have been murdered. Panic ensues as they realize that they are stranded in a snowbound inn with a potential killer among them. David, with his legal background, tries to take control and calm the group, suggesting that they wait out the storm together.
Suspicion and Paranoia Grow
As the hours pass, suspicion shifts among the guests. Tensions run high, and each guest becomes wary of the others. They attempt to barricade themselves in separate rooms, and alliances form and dissolve based on assumptions and fears. With everyone on edge, the atmosphere becomes suffused with paranoia, and the characters' personalities and hidden conflicts begin to emerge under the pressure. Riley’s anxiety is exacerbated, and Beverly and Henry’s marital discord becomes more pronounced.
The Second Murder
A second death occurs when another guest, Matthew, is found dead, this time with clear evidence of foul play. His body shows signs of struggle, indicating that someone deliberately killed him. This murder removes any remaining doubt: there is a killer in the inn. The survivors begin searching for potential motives, combing through each other’s backgrounds and behaviors for clues. Candice, in particular, becomes more introspective, almost detached, as she mentally analyzes each of the others as possible suspects.
“In the quiet, eerie stillness of the snowbound inn, each heartbeat felt like a countdown, each glance a silent accusation.”
Descent into Chaos
With two people dead, the group starts to unravel. Gwen and Riley, who have leaned on each other for support, grow fearful and isolate themselves. Henry becomes defensive, particularly when his wife Beverly suggests they might be safer elsewhere. David, meanwhile, uses his experience to keep everyone focused, but his own motivations are soon questioned. Some guests suspect that he may have secrets, and his calm demeanor is unsettling to others.
The Final Murders
One by one, more guests are found dead, each in a progressively more horrifying manner. Fear and distrust reach a climax, with everyone wondering who might be next and whether they can trust anyone at all. As the body count rises, survivors are forced into desperate attempts to survive, barricading doors and forming temporary alliances, though no one feels truly safe. The claustrophobic atmosphere and inescapable setting add to the sense of entrapment and terror, with each character’s vulnerabilities laid bare.
The Shocking Revelation
In a shocking twist, it’s revealed that Candice, the quiet, observant author, is the killer. Her motives are complex, rooted in a deep-seated resentment and a twisted desire for control. As an author who thrives on creating characters and plots, she sees her actions as a morbid, real-life story where she has the ultimate power. Her calculated behavior allowed her to observe and manipulate the other guests, carefully eliminating them one by one. Candice’s cold-blooded nature contrasts sharply with the vulnerability and fear of the others, emphasizing her sense of superiority and detachment.
“She was not merely a guest in the story, she was the author—writing the endings of others with chilling precision.”
The Final Confrontation and Resolution
The few remaining guests confront Candice in a tense showdown. She initially attempts to justify her actions, viewing her crimes as a darkly creative exercise. However, the remaining survivors overpower her, bringing an end to her killing spree. The police finally arrive after the storm subsides, uncovering the horrifying scene at Mitchell’s Inn. The survivors are left grappling with the trauma of the experience, forever changed by the violent events of the weekend.
4. Key Themes and Symbols
Isolation and Claustrophobia:
The snowstorm isolates the characters physically, while the lack of communication and power symbolizes their vulnerability and inability to escape. This isolation heightens their sense of helplessness and paranoia.Trust and Betrayal:
As suspicion falls on each guest in turn, the novel explores the fragility of trust and the ease with which fear can turn friends into enemies. The characters’ inability to trust one another reflects the psychological toll of paranoia.Human Nature and Survival Instincts:
Each character’s reaction to the murders reveals their true nature under duress. Some attempt to rationalize the situation, while others become defensive or aggressive, showcasing the different facets of human behavior in life-threatening situations.Power and Control:
Candice’s calculated murders reflect her twisted need for control, turning her writing skills into a tool for real-life manipulation. Her view of the situation as a narrative she controls underscores the theme of power.
5. Climax and Resolution
The story reaches its climax with the revelation of Candice as the killer. Her detached, clinical approach to murder shocks the remaining guests, leading to a final confrontation that ultimately stops her. The resolution is bittersweet, as the surviving characters are left to process the trauma of their ordeal and the loss of their fellow guests.
Conclusion
An Unwanted Guest is a taut, suspenseful thriller that delves into the psychology of fear, mistrust, and survival under extreme conditions. Lapena’s use of a classic locked-room mystery trope, combined with modern psychological tension, makes for a compelling read. The novel’s isolated setting and suspenseful pacing keep readers on edge, while its exploration of human vulnerability and betrayal resonates on a deeper level. In the end, An Unwanted Guest stands as a testament to Lapena’s skill in blending classic mystery elements with chilling psychological insight.